Trade Analysis

Dynasty Half-PPR 12 Teams Superflex/2QB OFF TE Prem OFF Package Adj. OFF

Overall Assessment

Absolutely not

While you'd be getting the most valuable asset in the trade in Tyler Shough, you'd be giving up a bit too much to make it happen. Therefore, we don't think you should make this trade.

Giving 

Total Value
72.2
Trey Benson
rb • Cardinals
$20.4
Adonai Mitchell
wr • Jets
$19.2
Michael Penix Jr.
qb • Falcons
$13.7
Marvin Mims
wr • Broncos
$12.9
Jacksonville Jaguars
def • Jaguars
$6.0

Getting 

Total Value
45.9
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
$21.1
Tua Tagovailoa
qb • Falcons
$16.9
Philadelphia Eagles
def • Eagles
$7.9
Roster Spot
 
Roster Spot
 

Value Gap: 26.3

EVEN Giving: 72.2 Getting: 45.9 Show example players to bridge the gap

Giving Pros & Cons

Trey Benson
rb • Cardinals
20.4
If healthy in 2026, has as much chance as anyone to be Arizona's backup behind Jeremiyah Love.
Fast (4.39 40-yard dash) & powerful back (6'1", 216) with a knack for breaking tackles.
Long term prospects not so bright with Jeremiyah Love in town.
Pass pro needs development if he's ever going to ascend to a more significant role.
Adonai Mitchell
wr • Jets
19.2
Excellent size and speed (6'2", 205 lbs with a 4.34 40-yard dash).
Was better with the Jets than the Colts, so could be productive opposite a healthy Garrett Wilson in 2026.
Who his quarterback will be remains an issue, as does his inconsistent route running.
Michael Penix Jr.
qb • Falcons
13.7
Surrounded by top-level talent.
Tua's arrival could mean end of his time as a starter.
Recovering from knee injury that ended his 2025 season.
Marvin Mims
wr • Broncos
12.9
Huge deep-threat potential.
Only managed a 37-322-1 season in 2025.
Jacksonville Jaguars
def • Jaguars
6.0
No pros or cons for this player yet.

Getting Pros & Cons

Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
21.1
Took over as the Saints starter in 2025 and played very well down the stretch. Should be the guy in 2026.
Not a true dual-threat QB, but runs effectively at opportune times which raises his fantasy ceiling.
Still young and developing on a rebuilding team, so production will likely be inconsistent.
Tua Tagovailoa
qb • Falcons
16.9
Will likely be Falcons Week 1 starter.
Concussion history will be a concern for the rest of his career.
Purely a pocket passer with very little rushing value.
Philadelphia Eagles
def • Eagles
7.9
No pros or cons for this player yet.

Chance the other team accepts

71%

Other team's likely reaction

Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Trey Benson
rb • Cardinals
20.4
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
106
YD
487
TD
4
Receiving
TAR
15
REC
14
YD
96
TD
1
Points
STD
88
PPR
102
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@LAC
Week 2
vSEA
Week 3
@SF
Week 4
@NYG
Week 5
vDET
Week 6
@LAR
Week 7
vDEN
Week 8
@DAL
Week 9
@SEA
Week 10
vLAR
Week 11
@KC
Week 12
vWAS
Week 13
vPHI
Week 14
BYE
Week 15
vNYJ
Week 16
@NO
Week 17
vLVR
Week 18
vSF
Adonai Mitchell
wr • Jets
19.2
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
55
REC
30
YD
429
TD
3
Rushing
ATT
6
YD
31
TD
0
Points
STD
64
PPR
94
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@TEN
Week 2
vGB
Week 3
@DET
Week 4
@CHI
Week 5
vCLE
Week 6
@NE
Week 7
vMIA
Week 8
vLVR
Week 9
@KC
Week 10
vBUF
Week 11
@LAC
Week 12
@MIA
Week 13
BYE
Week 14
vDEN
Week 15
@ARZ
Week 16
vNE
Week 17
vMIN
Week 18
@BUF
Michael Penix Jr.
qb • Falcons
13.7
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
77
COMP
59
YD
531
TD
6
INT
3
Rushing
ATT
8
YD
40
TD
2
Points
STD
67
PPR
67
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@PIT
Week 2
vCAR
Week 3
@GB
Week 4
@NO
Week 5
vBAL
Week 6
vCHI
Week 7
vSF
Week 8
@TB
Week 9
@CIN
Week 10
vKC
Week 11
BYE
Week 12
@MIN
Week 13
vDET
Week 14
@CLE
Week 15
@WAS
Week 16
vTB
Week 17
vNO
Week 18
@CAR
Marvin Mims
wr • Broncos
12.9
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
56
REC
34
YD
502
TD
2
Rushing
ATT
25
YD
113
TD
2
Points
STD
86
PPR
120
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@KC
Week 2
vJAX
Week 3
vLAR
Week 4
@SF
Week 5
@LAC
Week 6
vSEA
Week 7
@ARZ
Week 8
vKC
Week 9
@CAR
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vLVR
Week 12
@PIT
Week 13
vMIA
Week 14
@NYJ
Week 15
@LVR
Week 16
vBUF
Week 17
@NE
Week 18
vLAC
Jacksonville Jaguars
def • Jaguars
6.0
2026 Schedule
Week 1
vCLE
Week 2
@DEN
Week 3
vNE
Week 4
@CIN
Week 5
@PHI
Week 6
@HOU
Week 7
BYE
Week 8
vIND
Week 9
@BAL
Week 10
@TEN
Week 11
@NYG
Week 12
vTEN
Week 13
@CHI
Week 14
vPIT
Week 15
@HOU
Week 16
@DAL
Week 17
vWAS
Week 18
@IND

Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
21.1
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
501
COMP
337
YD
3499
TD
21
INT
5
Rushing
ATT
24
YD
128
TD
1
Points
STD
278
PPR
278
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@DET
Week 2
@BAL
Week 3
vLVR
Week 4
vATL
Week 5
vMIN
Week 6
@NYG
Week 7
@PIT
Week 8
BYE
Week 9
vCLE
Week 10
vCAR
Week 11
@CHI
Week 12
@CIN
Week 13
vGB
Week 14
@CAR
Week 15
@TB
Week 16
vARZ
Week 17
@ATL
Week 18
vTB
Tua Tagovailoa
qb • Falcons
16.9
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
482
COMP
319
YD
3428
TD
19
INT
13
Rushing
ATT
34
YD
124
TD
1
Points
STD
266
PPR
266
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@PIT
Week 2
vCAR
Week 3
@GB
Week 4
@NO
Week 5
vBAL
Week 6
vCHI
Week 7
vSF
Week 8
@TB
Week 9
@CIN
Week 10
vKC
Week 11
BYE
Week 12
@MIN
Week 13
vDET
Week 14
@CLE
Week 15
@WAS
Week 16
vTB
Week 17
vNO
Week 18
@CAR
Philadelphia Eagles
def • Eagles
7.9
2026 Schedule
Week 1
vWAS
Week 2
@TEN
Week 3
@CHI
Week 4
vLAR
Week 5
vJAX
Week 6
vCAR
Week 7
vDAL
Week 8
@WAS
Week 9
vNYG
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vPIT
Week 12
@DAL
Week 13
@ARZ
Week 14
vIND
Week 15
vSEA
Week 16
vHOU
Week 17
@SF
Week 18
@NYG

What Next?

Edit current trade Analyze a new trade Share results
New in 2026

League Import

Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.

Import a league See example results

Gear Up for 2026


Championship Trophies

Draft Boards

Championship Rings

Championship Belts