Trade Analysis

Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex/2QB ON TE Prem ON Package Adj. ON

Overall Assessment

Very close, but no

This is an extremely close deal, but you'd be unloading the best asset in the trade (Tucker Kraft) and not getting quite enough value back for us to recommend pulling the trigger on it.

Keep in mind, while we wouldn't do this trade in a vacuum, if you have other good options at TE and have a big need at RB, then it might make sense to go through with it.

Getting 

Total Value
137.0
Bucky Irving
rb • Buccaneers
$56.2
2026 #1.05
pick • Rookie Pick
$41.0
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
$39.8

Value Gap: 2.5

EVEN Giving: 139.5 Getting: 137.0

Giving Pros & Cons

Tucker Kraft
te • Packers
58.1
Great size & athleticism combination should lead to elite YAC and contested catch ability.
Was dominating before injury ended his season.
Returning from an ACL tear in Week 9 of last season.
Christian McCaffrey
rb • 49ers
46.8
Dynamic dual-threat player is always in the overall RB1 conversation if he stays healthy.
Even when YPC is down (like in 2025), still gets enough pass-game action to put up elite numbers.
Turns 30 before the season and is coming off a heavy workload in 2025.
Josh Jacobs
rb • Packers
34.6
Consistent player who should produce Top 15 numbers if he stays healthy.
Showed some declines in efficiency last season.
Injuries a concern due to heavy usage over the past 5 seasons.

Getting Pros & Cons

Bucky Irving
rb • Buccaneers
56.2
Amassed 1,514 total yards in 2024 as a rookie, flashing agility and explosiveness.
Excellent receiver with three-down potential.
Smaller size could limit his workhorse potential.
Only played 10 games last season due to injuries. Will he bounce back to rookie season form?
2026 #1.05
pick • Rookie Pick
41.0
Draft picks do not have pros or cons.
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
39.8
Took over as the Saints starter in 2025 and played very well down the stretch. Should be the guy in 2026.
Not a true dual-threat QB, but runs effectively at opportune times which raises his fantasy ceiling.
Still young and developing on a rebuilding team, so production will likely be inconsistent.

Chance the other team accepts

48%

Other team's likely reaction

Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Tucker Kraft
te • Packers
58.1
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
79
REC
57
YD
658
TD
6
Rushing
ATT
0
YD
0
TD
0
Points
STD
102
PPR
159
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Christian McCaffrey
rb • 49ers
46.8
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
237
YD
1134
TD
9
Receiving
TAR
73
REC
60
YD
511
TD
3
Points
STD
237
PPR
297
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Josh Jacobs
rb • Packers
34.6
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
269
YD
1205
TD
11
Receiving
TAR
44
REC
33
YD
287
TD
2
Points
STD
227
PPR
260
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD

Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Bucky Irving
rb • Buccaneers
56.2
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
228
YD
1109
TD
6
Receiving
TAR
60
REC
51
YD
391
TD
4
Points
STD
210
PPR
261
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
2026 #1.05
pick • Rookie Pick
41.0
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
39.8
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
401
COMP
257
YD
3078
TD
21
INT
5
Rushing
ATT
24
YD
128
TD
1
Points
STD
257
PPR
257
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD

Recent Related Trades

03/26/26
Dynasty PPR 10 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem ON
03/24/26
Dynasty Half-PPR 10 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem OFF
03/23/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex OFF TE Prem OFF
03/22/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex OFF TE Prem OFF
03/22/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex OFF TE Prem ON
New in 2026

League Import

Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.

Import a league See example results