Trade Analysis
Dynasty
PPR
12 Teams
Superflex/2QB OFF
TE Prem OFF
Package Adj. ON
Overall Assessment
Nope.
Yes, you'd be acquiring the most valuable asset in the trade in Malik Nabers, but the overall value you'd be getting doesn't match the value you'd be giving up, so our advice is to not make this deal.
Keep in mind, while we wouldn't do this trade in a vacuum, if you have other solid options at RB and are desperate at WR, then it might make sense to go through with it.
Giving 
Total Value
134.1
James Cook
rb • Bills
$61.2
DK Metcalf
wr • Steelers
$39.9
2026 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
$23.0
2026 #2.09
pick • Rookie Pick
$10.0
Getting 
Total Value
123.7
Malik Nabers 
wr • Giants
$70.9
Quinshon Judkins
rb • Browns
$38.8
Roster Spot
Roster Spot
Value Gap: 10.4
Show example players to bridge the gapGiving Pros & Cons
James Cook
rb • Bills
61.2
Career-high rushing yards in 2025 with 1,621, which led the entire NFL.
Solid pass-catching ability combined with QB Josh Allen gives him a solid fantasy floor.
Josh Allen's rushing prowess can limit Cook's goal line chances.
DK Metcalf
wr • Steelers
39.9
Elite physical WR who sees high volume of red-zone targets.
First year in Pitt produced lowest receptions since his rookie year and lowest yards of his career.
Now sharing targets with Michael Pittman.
2026 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
23.0
Draft picks do not have pros or cons.
2026 #2.09
pick • Rookie Pick
10.0
Draft picks do not have pros or cons.
Getting Pros & Cons
Malik Nabers
wr • Giants
70.9
If healthy, could explode playing with promising QB Jaxson Dart.
Versatile player who excels on both deep balls and shorter chain-moving passes.
ACL injury in Week 4 ended his 2025 season. Some reports of recovery time being extended.
Quinshon Judkins
rb • Browns
38.8
Had 230 carries in his rookie season before injuring his ankle. Should be the RB1 in 2026.
Limited passing game role lowers his PPR value and overall ceiling.
Chance the other team accepts
55%
Other team's likely reaction
Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings
James Cook
rb • Bills
61.2
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
229
YD
1019
TD
11
Receiving
TAR
44
REC
36
YD
290
TD
3
Points
STD
215
PPR
251
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
DK Metcalf
wr • Steelers
39.9
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
119
REC
73
YD
1004
TD
7
Rushing
ATT
0
YD
0
TD
0
Points
STD
142
PPR
215
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
2026 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
23.0
2026 #2.09
pick • Rookie Pick
10.0
Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings
Malik Nabers
wr • Giants
70.9
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
169
REC
109
YD
1322
TD
8
Rushing
ATT
5
YD
33
TD
0
Points
STD
184
PPR
293
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Quinshon Judkins
rb • Browns
38.8
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
202
YD
851
TD
5
Receiving
TAR
45
REC
33
YD
230
TD
1
Points
STD
144
PPR
177
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Recent Related Trades
What Next?
New in 2026
League Import
Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.
Import a league See example results
