Trade Analysis

Dynasty Half-PPR 12 Teams Superflex/2QB ON TE Prem OFF Package Adj. ON

Overall Assessment

Close, but no

Even though this deal is fair and you'd be acquiring the most valuable asset in the trade in Justin Herbert, we prefer the overall value on your side slightly more, so we wouldn't suggest making this trade.

Giving 

Total Value
111.3
Malik Willis
qb • Dolphins
$40.1
Jonah Coleman
rb • Broncos
$22.2
J.K. Dobbins
rb • Broncos
$20.0
2027 #2.01
pick • Rookie Pick
$17.0
2028 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
$12.0

Getting 

Total Value
103.8
Justin Herbert
qb • Chargers
$49.8
D'Andre Swift
rb • Bears
$30.0
Roster Spot
 
Roster Spot
 
Roster Spot
 

Value Gap: 7.5

EVEN Giving: 111.3 Getting: 103.8

Giving Pros & Cons

Malik Willis
qb • Dolphins
40.1
Rushing ability should give him a high fantasy floor.
Signed with the Dolphins, whose new HC Jeff Hafley saw Willis perform rather well in 2025 in Green Bay.
Very limited track record so busting as a starter is not off the table.
Jonah Coleman
rb • Broncos
22.2
Physical profile of a three-down back.
Nose for the end zone, having scored 17 TDs in 2025.
Lacks the elite speed NFL evaluators like to see.
J.K. Dobbins
rb • Broncos
20.0
If he gets back to full health, could provide some value in 2026.
Significant injury history having played less than 50% of games since 2020.
Back in Denver, he will be in a committee with RJ Harvey at best.
2027 #2.01
pick • Rookie Pick
17.0
Draft picks do not have pros or cons.
2028 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
12.0
Draft picks do not have pros or cons.

Getting Pros & Cons

Justin Herbert
qb • Chargers
49.8
The rare gunslinger who maintains a strong TD:INT ratio by taking care of the ball.
When scheme allows, capable of producing massive yardage totals
Run-heavy scheme limits Herbert's upside (less than 31 pass attempts per game in 2025),
Historically inconsistent production with a mix of both elite weeks and dud weeks.
D'Andre Swift
rb • Bears
30.0
Likely to remain the 1A to Kyle Monangai's 1B, which should provide solid fantasy numbers in Ben Johnson's offense.
Bounced back in 2025, rushing for over 1,000 yards and a 4.9 YPC (up from 3.8 in 2024).
Monangai showed out as a rookie and will continue to eat into Swift's touches.

Chance the other team accepts

53%

Other team's likely reaction

Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Malik Willis
qb • Dolphins
40.1
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
450
COMP
301
YD
3318
TD
12
INT
9
Rushing
ATT
77
YD
372
TD
3
Points
STD
269
PPR
269
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@LVR
Week 2
@SF
Week 3
vKC
Week 4
@MIN
Week 5
vCIN
Week 6
BYE
Week 7
@NYJ
Week 8
vNE
Week 9
vDET
Week 10
@IND
Week 11
@BUF
Week 12
vNYJ
Week 13
@DEN
Week 14
vCHI
Week 15
@GB
Week 16
vLAC
Week 17
vBUF
Week 18
@NE
Jonah Coleman
rb • Broncos
22.2
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
81
YD
368
TD
2
Receiving
TAR
0
REC
0
YD
0
TD
0
Points
STD
49
PPR
49
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@KC
Week 2
vJAX
Week 3
vLAR
Week 4
@SF
Week 5
@LAC
Week 6
vSEA
Week 7
@ARZ
Week 8
vKC
Week 9
@CAR
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vLVR
Week 12
@PIT
Week 13
vMIA
Week 14
@NYJ
Week 15
@LVR
Week 16
vBUF
Week 17
@NE
Week 18
vLAC
J.K. Dobbins
rb • Broncos
20.0
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
180
YD
911
TD
6
Receiving
TAR
40
REC
31
YD
188
TD
1
Points
STD
152
PPR
183
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@KC
Week 2
vJAX
Week 3
vLAR
Week 4
@SF
Week 5
@LAC
Week 6
vSEA
Week 7
@ARZ
Week 8
vKC
Week 9
@CAR
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vLVR
Week 12
@PIT
Week 13
vMIA
Week 14
@NYJ
Week 15
@LVR
Week 16
vBUF
Week 17
@NE
Week 18
vLAC
2027 #2.01
pick • Rookie Pick
17.0
2028 #1.12
pick • Rookie Pick
12.0

Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Justin Herbert
qb • Chargers
49.8
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
516
COMP
338
YD
3793
TD
22
INT
10
Rushing
ATT
55
YD
212
TD
2
Points
STD
311
PPR
311
2026 Schedule
Week 1
vARZ
Week 2
vLVR
Week 3
@BUF
Week 4
@SEA
Week 5
vDEN
Week 6
@KC
Week 7
BYE
Week 8
@LAR
Week 9
vHOU
Week 10
@BAL
Week 11
vNYJ
Week 12
vNE
Week 13
@TB
Week 14
@LVR
Week 15
vSF
Week 16
@MIA
Week 17
vKC
Week 18
@DEN
D'Andre Swift
rb • Bears
30.0
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
241
YD
998
TD
7
Receiving
TAR
43
REC
35
YD
269
TD
2
Points
STD
181
PPR
216
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@CAR
Week 2
vMIN
Week 3
vPHI
Week 4
vNYJ
Week 5
@GB
Week 6
@ATL
Week 7
vNE
Week 8
@SEA
Week 9
vTB
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vNO
Week 12
@DET
Week 13
vJAX
Week 14
@MIA
Week 15
@BUF
Week 16
vGB
Week 17
vDET
Week 18
@MIN
New in 2026

League Import

Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.

Import a league See example results