Trade Analysis

Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex/2QB OFF TE Prem OFF Package Adj. ON

Overall Assessment

Extremely fair, but no

We have these two valued just about the same so it's essentially a coin toss. Ultimately, we like Caleb Williams slightly more than Patrick Mahomes so it's a no for us.

Giving 

Getting 

Value Gap: 0.5

EVEN Giving: 31.1 Getting: 30.6

Giving Pros & Cons

Caleb Williams
qb • Bears
31.1
Should continue improving under head coach Ben Johnson, who is a great offensive mind.
After a tough rookie season, Williams made huge strides in 2025, leading the Bears to a division title.
Inconsistency remains an issue that will need to be worked on in order to take the next step.
Often holds the ball too long, which results in bad sacks or hero-ball throws that sometimes end badly.

Getting Pros & Cons

Patrick Mahomes
qb • Chiefs
30.6
Despite his serious late season injury, he is targeting a Week 1 return in 2026. Time will tell.
May not run as much as he has in the past, but remains an elite passer with elite football IQ.
Offense was underwhelming in 2025 and lacked explosiveness. Mahomes had an uncharacteristic 11 INTs.
Recovering from major ACL & LCL injury suffered late in 2025 season, so timeline to return AND be effective is uncertain.

Chance the other team accepts

46%

Other team's likely reaction

Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Caleb Williams
qb • Bears
31.1
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
571
COMP
360
YD
4089
TD
25
INT
8
Rushing
ATT
67
YD
401
TD
1
Points
STD
351
PPR
351
2026 Schedule
Week 1
@CAR
Week 2
vMIN
Week 3
vPHI
Week 4
vNYJ
Week 5
@GB
Week 6
@ATL
Week 7
vNE
Week 8
@SEA
Week 9
vTB
Week 10
BYE
Week 11
vNO
Week 12
@DET
Week 13
vJAX
Week 14
@MIA
Week 15
@BUF
Week 16
vGB
Week 17
vDET
Week 18
@MIN

Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Patrick Mahomes
qb • Chiefs
30.6
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
559
COMP
375
YD
4111
TD
28
INT
12
Rushing
ATT
66
YD
328
TD
3
Points
STD
368
PPR
368
2026 Schedule
Week 1
vDEN
Week 2
vIND
Week 3
@MIA
Week 4
@LVR
Week 5
BYE
Week 6
vLAC
Week 7
@SEA
Week 8
@DEN
Week 9
vNYJ
Week 10
@ATL
Week 11
vARZ
Week 12
@BUF
Week 13
@LAR
Week 14
@CIN
Week 15
vNE
Week 16
vSF
Week 17
@LAC
Week 18
vLVR
New in 2026

League Import

Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.

Import a league See example results