Trade Analysis
Dynasty
Half-PPR
10 Teams
Superflex/2QB ON
TE Prem ON
Package Adj. ON
Overall Assessment
Very close, but no
Wow, this is especially close AND you'd be acquiring the most valuable asset in the trade in Jonathan Taylor. That normally means you should go ahead with the deal, but we're going to say don't make this trade because we still prefer (albeit ever so slightly) the overall value on your side.
Keep in mind, while we wouldn't do this trade in a vacuum, if you have other good options at QB and have a big need at RB, then it might make sense to go through with it.
Giving 
Getting 
Value Gap: 1.0
Giving Pros & Cons
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
39.8
Not a true dual-threat QB, but runs effectively at opportune times which raises his fantasy ceiling.
Took over as the Saints starter in 2025 and played very well down the stretch. Should be the guy in 2026.
Still young and developing on a rebuilding team, so production will likely be inconsistent.
Tyrone Tracy
rb • Giants
22.2
Was Giants' lead back once Cam Skattebo got hurt, finishing with 176 carries, 740 yards and 2 TDs.
The featured role will likely go back to Skattebo once he returns from injury.
Kyle Williams
wr • Patriots
15.0
Modest size (5'11", 190) but capable of playing both inside and outside.
Showed deep-threat prowess with 20.9 yards per catch in 2025.
Small catch radius and underwhelming hands that have been unreliable at times.
Getting Pros & Cons
Jonathan Taylor
rb • Colts
62.0
Catches a lot of passes and is used heavily in goal line situations.
Proven elite talent with explosive, big-play ability when healthy.
Extensive injury history provides some cause for concern.
Breakaway speed has diminished a bit, lowering his ceiling.
Chance the other team accepts
46%
Other team's likely reaction
Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings
Tyler Shough
qb • Saints
39.8
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
401
COMP
257
YD
3078
TD
21
INT
5
Rushing
ATT
24
YD
128
TD
1
Points
STD
257
PPR
257
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Tyrone Tracy
rb • Giants
22.2
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
165
YD
730
TD
3
Receiving
TAR
28
REC
21
YD
181
TD
1
Points
STD
115
PPR
136
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Kyle Williams
wr • Patriots
15.0
Projections for 2026
Receiving
TAR
50
REC
30
YD
348
TD
2
Rushing
ATT
1
YD
7
TD
0
Points
STD
48
PPR
78
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings
Jonathan Taylor
rb • Colts
62.0
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
308
YD
1438
TD
11
Receiving
TAR
39
REC
28
YD
220
TD
2
Points
STD
244
PPR
272
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Recent Related Trades
What Next?
New in 2026
League Import
Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.
Import a league See example results
