Trade Analysis

Redraft PPR Superflex/2QB OFF TE Prem OFF Package Adj. ON

Overall Assessment

Absolutely not

On one hand, you'd be getting the most valuable asset in the trade in Caleb Williams. On the other hand, you're giving up a bit too much to make it happen. Therefore, we suggest not making this trade.

Getting 

Total Value
35.1
Caleb Williams
qb • Bears
$29.1
Roster Spot
 

Giving Pros & Cons

Justin Herbert
qb • Chargers
28.9
When scheme allows, capable of producing massive yardage totals
The rare gunslinger who maintains a strong TD:INT ratio by taking care of the ball.
Run-heavy scheme limits Herbert's upside (less than 31 pass attempts per game in 2025),
Historically inconsistent production with a mix of both elite weeks and dud weeks.
Quinshon Judkins
rb • Browns
28.4
Had 230 carries in his rookie season before injuring his ankle. Should be the RB1 in 2026.
Limited passing game role lowers his PPR value and overall ceiling.

Getting Pros & Cons

Caleb Williams
qb • Bears
29.1
After a tough rookie season, Williams made huge strides in 2025, leading the Bears to a division title.
Should continue improving under head coach Ben Johnson, who is a great offensive mind.
Inconsistency remains an issue that will need to be worked on in order to take the next step.
Often holds the ball too long, which results in bad sacks or hero-ball throws that sometimes end badly.

Chance the other team accepts

67%

Other team's likely reaction

Giving Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Justin Herbert
qb • Chargers
28.9
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
516
COMP
338
YD
3793
TD
22
INT
10
Rushing
ATT
55
YD
212
TD
2
Points
STD
311
PPR
311
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD
Quinshon Judkins
rb • Browns
28.4
Projections for 2026
Rushing
ATT
202
YD
851
TD
5
Receiving
TAR
45
REC
33
YD
230
TD
1
Points
STD
144
PPR
177
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD

Getting Projections, Stats, Schedules & Future Matchup Ratings

Caleb Williams
qb • Bears
29.1
Projections for 2026
Passing
ATT
571
COMP
360
YD
4089
TD
25
INT
8
Rushing
ATT
67
YD
401
TD
1
Points
STD
351
PPR
351
2026 Schedule
Week 1
TBD
Week 2
TBD
Week 3
TBD
Week 4
TBD
Week 5
TBD
Week 6
TBD
Week 7
TBD
Week 8
TBD
Week 9
TBD
Week 10
TBD
Week 11
TBD
Week 12
TBD
Week 13
TBD
Week 14
TBD
Week 15
TBD
Week 16
TBD
Week 17
TBD
Week 18
TBD

Recent Related Trades

03/29/26
Dynasty PPR 10 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem OFF
Giving
2026 #1.05
Caleb Williams
Getting
2027 #1.06
Justin Herbert
03/29/26
Dynasty PPR 10 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem OFF
Giving
2026 #1.05
Caleb Williams
Getting
Justin Herbert
2026 #2.03
03/24/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem ON
03/24/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem ON
03/21/26
Dynasty PPR 12 Teams Superflex ON TE Prem OFF
New in 2026

League Import

Import your entire league in seconds and share analysis with your leaguemates. Currently available for ESPN, Sleeper, MFL and Yahoo.

Import a league See example results